Worcester City FC owner Simon Lancaster discusses proposals to change football’s alcohol rules, the experience of drinking pitchside in non-league football and whether modern matchdays have moved on from the problems of the 1980s.
The debate around drinking alcohol in football stands has returned following Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s comments that the existing restrictions should be reconsidered.
Current legislation prevents supporters from drinking alcohol within sight of the pitch at designated matches involving clubs in the top five tiers of English men’s football. Burnham has argued that the rules reflect a different era of football and suggested that changes could potentially be trialled. Police representatives have urged consultation and a full consideration of the potential safety implications before any changes are made.
Speaking during a radio discussion, Worcester City FC owner Simon Lancaster offered the perspective of a non-league club where supporters are already accustomed to being able to enjoy a drink while watching the game.
Simon believes the experience at Worcester City demonstrates how drinking pitchside can form part of the matchday experience, although he acknowledged some of the practical concerns that could arise if similar rules were introduced at larger, predominantly seated stadiums. Pasted text
Drinking at Football From a Non-League Perspective
At Worcester City’s level, supporters can normally drink while watching matches, and Simon says it is something many fans enjoy.
In fact, he believes it provides non-league football with a point of difference. Some supporters choose to attend Worcester City matches partly because of the more relaxed matchday experience, which includes being able to have a drink while watching the action.
That means changing the rules higher up the football pyramid could potentially remove one of non-league football’s attractions.
Despite that, Simon says he supports reconsidering the restrictions when looking at the issue more broadly.
Has Football Changed Since the Alcohol Ban Was Introduced?
One of Simon’s main arguments is that the football environment has changed considerably since restrictions were introduced in the 1980s.
He acknowledges that the rules made sense against the backdrop of the hooliganism and disorder associated with football during that period. However, he believes today’s crowds are different, with football becoming a much more family-orientated experience.
Simon points to the number of families, women and children now attending matches and argues that the modern matchday should be considered in that context.
He also believes allowing supporters to have a drink while watching could make attending a match more appealing to people who are interested in the wider social experience as much as the football itself.
Could Drinking in the Stands Create Practical Problems?
The discussion also raised some of the potential disadvantages of changing the rules.
At larger all-seater stadiums, supporters repeatedly leaving their seats to buy drinks or use the facilities could cause disruption for those around them. Other concerns raised during the programme included excessive drinking, beer being thrown during celebrations and ensuring that football remains welcoming to supporters who do not drink alcohol.
Simon acknowledged that the issue of supporters repeatedly moving in and out of their seats was a valid concern that would need to be considered.
However, his overall view remains that the game has changed enough for the existing approach to be reconsidered.
Worcester City Already Experiences Both Sets of Rules
Worcester City also provides an unusual example of how the current regulations can create confusion.
Simon explained that supporters are normally able to drink while watching Worcester City’s non-league fixtures. However, different restrictions can apply when the club faces higher-ranking opposition in certain cup competitions or pre-season friendlies.
Fans who are accustomed to taking their drinks pitchside can therefore suddenly find themselves being stopped by stewards during a different fixture at the same club.
Simon believes this illustrates some of the complications created by having different rules depending on the level and type of fixture being played. Pasted text
Balancing Matchday Experience, Revenue and Safety
For football clubs, there is also a commercial consideration. Allowing supporters to purchase drinks for longer periods could provide an additional source of matchday revenue, something that can be particularly valuable lower down the football pyramid.
Simon believes it can also contribute to the overall experience of attending a game.
However, the wider discussion highlighted that any change would need to consider more than additional revenue. Safety, crowd behaviour, disruption in seated areas, inclusivity and the potential impact on pubs surrounding stadiums were all raised as factors that would need to form part of the debate. Pasted text
For Simon, the experience of non-league football suggests there is an argument for reconsidering rules created more than four decades ago, while recognising that introducing similar arrangements at larger stadiums would bring practical questions that need to be addressed.
Watch The Full Interview Here
Full Interview Transcript
Interviewer: We’re going to talk about the Prime Minister’s announcement yesterday in New York that he would like to see a change in the law around being able to drink within sight of the pitch at football grounds.
Charlie, you said you’ve got a weird little thing that goes on at Torquay where, because you’re a segregated ground still, people can’t have a drink.
Charlie: I think it’s because we’ve been in a higher division before and we’re a segregated ground that, when people come to us, they can’t drink within sight of the pitch.
Other teams in non-league can. I’m going to Billericay v Torquay on Saturday and, if I wanted to, I’d have a pint on the terraces. Lots of people do it in non-league and they enjoy it, and I’m sure it’s a brilliant income stream for lower-league clubs.
But do you want my three reasons I don’t like it, Paul?
Interviewer: Just very quickly, Charlie. Yeah, go for it.
Charlie: The up and down. I think it works in non-league because it’s not really seated. People are in and out and standing up anyway.
But for you at Spurs, you’re going to be up and down all the time as people get in and out, getting a pint and going to the toilet.
We don’t need it. The game is enough. A lot of people seem to want to take away from how good the actual game of football is. You don’t need a drink all the time.
It would make going to the match twice as expensive. Not everything has to have a drink attached to it. Just enjoy the football and have a pint at half-time and a pint at the end.
If people are drinking all the time, it creates a lot more problems than I think it solves.
Interviewer: Listening now, I think with a very different view on that, is the owner of Worcester City, who play in the Southern Premier Central, Simon Lancaster.
Hi, Simon.
Simon: Hello. Thanks for having me on.
Interviewer: It’s a pleasure. You heard Charlie’s take on it. As someone who’s a Premier League fan, I can see it being an issue with people constantly going in and out of their seats and potentially getting a bit livelier. What’s your take on it?
Simon: I think that’s a good point, to be fair. I hadn’t thought of the constant getting up and out. I think they might have to address that somehow.
But overall, I’m in favour of it.
We’re non-league, so we can drink at our games and fans love that. Obviously, you can’t when you get to the league clubs, and I don’t think it makes for as good a matchday experience, if I’m brutally honest.
Selfishly, it probably wouldn’t help us if they brought drinking in for the leagues because it might take fans away from us who enjoy coming to our games because they can have a drink and watch the game.
But I think the game has moved on so much from the 80s, when the ban was probably rightly brought in with the hooliganism and everything.
I think we’re ready now to bring it back, I would personally say. On balance, I’m in favour of it.
Interviewer: Henry Winter, seasoned football journalist, has been sounding people out and looking at polls of fans today, amongst other things.
One of the other worries that came to me was that I could see pictures occasionally of flare-ups because people have had too much to drink.
There’s also the possibility of a trial period and all the stakeholders being very honest about it afterwards. Are you in favour of that or are you very much against the whole idea?
Henry Winter: I can see the debate, particularly in the EFL, with budgets.
Interviewer: Henry is frozen. We’ll try and get him back.
Simon, from your point of view, it obviously is great because it’s revenue for your club, which is all-important. If you were the chairman of a Premier League club, do you think you’d be as keen?
Simon: I think so, yeah.
It’s revenue, but it also improves the matchday experience.
The type of people who go and watch football now is very different from the 80s when hooliganism was rife. It’s very family-friendly now.
I do go and watch Liverpool as well. We’re Liverpool fans. It’s very much families, women and children.
My wife hates football, but if she can have a drink, she’ll come along and enjoy the experience.
I think it’s a different crowd now and it’s a good matchday experience.
For the lads who are going to drink 10 pints before the game, they’re going to do that anyway. Probably one more at the game isn’t going to make that much more difference.
Fortunately, the violence is no longer as big a problem, thankfully. It’s a different crowd that goes and it’s an enjoyable matchday experience.
So, I think chairmen of league clubs would be in favour of bringing it back.
Our complication is that we’re allowed it in non-league, but when we play against league clubs in the cups, or when we’ve had pre-season friendlies against league teams, because their ranking is higher the rule comes in and our fans aren’t allowed to do it.
That really confuses them.
They’re used to normally doing it, then they go to get a drink and try to come back out and the steward takes it off them.
It’s confusing for us because we kind of straddle both rulings at times.
Interviewer: We’ve got Henry back. Sorry, Henry. Pick up where you were.
Henry Winter: I think the issue is less the actual consumption of alcohol.
The culture of games now is completely different from the 70s and 80s when we first started watching games.
It’s less an issue of trouble and more the fact that you’ve got this culture of everyone throwing their beer in the air. There’ll be an issue with a lot of people not particularly appreciating that.
On a serious note, the Premier League quite rightly talks about inclusivity. With a multicultural audience, there will be people who, because of their religious views, have an issue with alcohol, so I think it has to be very carefully thought through.
The Prime Minister is a football fan, and I’m sure he’s coming from a good place on this.
EFL clubs absolutely have to maximise their revenue, but also spare a thought for the fact that so many pubs in this country are going out of business. Think of the pubs around the ground and how it might affect them.
Interviewer: It’s interesting because rugby league is a sport with a very similar background. When you go to games, people generally do act sensibly.
So, there is a situation in another sport with a similar background where there isn’t an issue.
Henry Winter: But we’re also talking about the Americanisation of football and games being broken up.
You go to Twickenham and sit there and it’s like mini Mexican waves going off because someone comes in with a tray of four beers. Then two minutes later, they go back in the other direction.
I kind of want to watch the football.
Spurs are a fantastic example of how quickly they can dispense beer at half-time, and maybe we’ve got to work on issues like that.
Personally, I think there are bigger issues in football than the Prime Minister having a debate about that.
Interviewer: Henry, thank you. And Simon, thank you ever so much for your take as well. We do appreciate it.
That’s Henry Winter and Simon Lancaster, the owner of non-league Worcester City FC.